Gusto vs QuickBooks for Payroll: A Comprehensive Comparison for Business Owners

It can be challenging for many business owners to decide between payroll providers. When your organization is balancing the need for robust payroll management with seamless integration into your existing accounting software, you may feel overwhelmed by the multitude of options available. Fortunately, by examining two popular payroll solutions—Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll—you can find a payroll solution that simplifies your payroll processes and streamlines business operations.

In this post, we’ll explore the critical features of both platforms, delve into their pricing structures, and analyze their key functionalities—from direct deposit options like same-day direct deposits and next-day direct deposit to the extensive resource centers that guide payroll taxes and tax preparation. Whether your company is small or a mid-sized business, whether you have hourly workers, salaried employees, or international contractors, this comprehensive analysis will help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the Core Functions

QuickBooks Payroll: Integration and Accounting Excellence

QuickBooks Payroll, developed by Intuit QuickBooks, is well-known for its seamless integration with QuickBooks Online. This synergy between payroll software and accounting solutions is especially beneficial for businesses that already rely on QuickBooks Accounting for managing accounting records and financial reporting. Some of the key features of QuickBooks Payroll include:

• Seamless Integration: Directly sync your payroll with QuickBooks Online and benefit from effortless automatic tax calculations and bookkeeping automation. The integration capabilities extend to third-party integrations, ensuring your bank integration and chart of accounts remain consistent.
• Payroll Management: With features like unlimited payroll runs and comprehensive payroll services that cover federal taxes, payroll taxes, and automatic tax calculations, QuickBooks Online Payroll provides robust support for business operations.
• User-Friendly Interface and Dedicated Support: The system is designed with an intuitive interface, a dedicated support team, and expert setup options to help accounting firms and business owners manage payroll taxes and employee payments effectively.
• Flexible Deposit Options: QuickBooks Payroll offers options like same-day direct deposits and next-day direct deposit, ensuring employees receive their wages on time. This feature is particularly useful for ensuring employees' financial visibility and minimizing deposit delays.

Gusto: A Full-Service Payroll Provider With Enhanced Benefits Administration

In contrast, Gusto is renowned for offering a full-service payroll solution that places significant emphasis on employee benefits administration. It is not just a payroll platform but a comprehensive business software solution focused on employee onboarding, payroll service, and benefits management. Gusto’s key features include:

• Employee Benefits and Onboarding: Gusto provides employee self-service portals, customizable employee profiles, and employee handbooks that assist in employee onboarding and managing employee surveys. These features support talent management and job posting initiatives while also streamlining background check processes.
• Payroll and Benefits Administration: Gusto’s flexible payroll plans include a core plan, Simple plan, and Premium plan. Each of these plans accommodates a wide range of business sizes—from 0-49 Employees to (250-999 Employees)—and ensures business owners can manage everything from employee benefits (health benefits, dental, vision insurance, flexible spending accounts, commuter benefits, and health insurance plans) to additional benefits like health savings accounts and disability insurance.
• Advanced Payroll Features: With capabilities like automatic calculations for tax payments, advanced reporting, and next-day or same-day deposit features (such as same-day deposits available for banks on business days), Gusto supports both basic payroll and comprehensive payroll for mid-sized businesses.
• Integration and Time Tracking: Gusto integrates seamlessly with external accounting software bundles and even offers time tracking features, including mobile time tracking and QuickBooks Time compatibility for accurate employee hours and contractor management.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Payroll Taxes and Tax Calculations

Both QuickBooks Online Payroll and Gusto offer automatic tax calculations—a crucial element in managing payroll taxes. QuickBooks Payroll streamlines tax payment and tax preparation through its integration with accounting software, enabling automated tax calculations and direct filing. This is particularly beneficial for business owners who need to adhere to federal taxes and multi-state payroll guidelines.

Gusto, on the other hand, goes a step further by not only calculating taxes but also managing tax filings as part of its full-service payroll feature. This offers additional peace of mind for businesses that prefer an expert product with minimal manual intervention. Both platforms help reduce the risk of costly errors and align with the guidance on topics including ongoing changes to payroll taxes provided in their respective resource centers.

Direct Deposits and Payment Options

QuickBooks Payroll:

• Same-day direct deposits and next-day direct deposit options ensure that both salaried employees and hourly workers can access their funds without delay.
• The platform also supports direct deposit features that tie into its comprehensive payroll package, reducing the risk of deposit delays even on a morning of payday.

Gusto:

• Similar to QuickBooks, Gusto offers same-day direct deposits (when conditions are met) and next-day direct deposits to help businesses streamline employee payments. This approach ensures that contractor payments and employee payments are processed efficiently, meeting the payroll needs of even those businesses with additional contractor or international contractors.
• Additionally, Gusto supports unlimited payroll runs, making it ideal for companies looking to perform payroll before payday with a mobile payroll app.

Employee Benefits and AdministrationGusto’s Strength in Benefits Administration:

• Gusto is a standout platform for benefits administration, offering extensive employee benefits management that includes health benefits, health insurance, vision insurance, and additional options like life insurance and college savings plans.
• Their system supports flexible spending accounts, commuter benefits, and health savings accounts—components of a comprehensive payroll solution that enhance employee satisfaction.
• The employee self-service portal and employee onboarding tools enhance the overall experience, ensuring that business operations related to human resource tasks are executed smoothly.

QuickBooks Payroll:

• Although QuickBooks Payroll is robust in its payroll management, it integrates efficiently with QuickBooks Online and QuickBooks Online Advanced for those seeking additional features like a comprehensive chart of accounts and advanced reporting.
• QuickBooks’ payroll service is integrated into an accounting software bundle, offering a straightforward pricing structure with base fees and additional contractor pricing, making it a competitive choice for businesses that require accounting prowess.

Integration and Flexibility

QuickBooks Online Payroll:

• Offers seamless integration with QuickBooks Online and QuickBooks Online Advanced. This ensures that your accounting records, payroll processes, and time tracking features all work together harmoniously, delivering financial health insights and improved operational efficiency.
• Third-party integrations further extend the functionalities of QuickBooks Accounting, including its connection with mobile time tracking apps and external banking institutions.

Gusto:

• Gusto’s integration capabilities allow it to combine with various accounting systems and bookkeeping automation tools, such as QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping, ensuring that all aspects of payroll management are in sync.
• Furthermore, Gusto supports a wide range of payroll platforms and integrates with advanced tools like QuickBooks Time, essential for managing employee hours and ensuring accurate hire reporting.

Pricing Tiers and Additional Costs

When it comes to pricing, both QuickBooks Payroll and Gusto have clear pricing tiers tailored to different business sizes and needs.

QuickBooks Online Payroll Pricing:

• Offers multiple payroll plans, including QuickBooks Online Payroll Core, QuickBooks Online Payroll Premium, and QuickBooks Online Payroll Elite.
• Each tier is designed with a straightforward pricing structure that includes base fees and a fee per month per additional employee. Business owners appreciate this predictable cost model, which is complemented by a range of subscription benefits and monthly subscription services.
• Additional costs may arise for premium features or additional contractor payments, so it is crucial to consider the then-current price when planning your budget.

Gusto’s Pricing Plans:

• Similarly, Gusto provides a variety of payroll plans such as the core plan, Simple plan, and Premium plan—each offering a wide range of services from basic payroll to comprehensive payroll, which includes benefits administration capabilities.
• Gusto typically promotes an affordable price point that scales with your business, whether you have 0-49 Employees, (50-249 Employees, or (250-999 Employees. Their pricing plans cover services that include expert setup, onboarding tools, and access to video tutorials that help businesses understand payroll management, employee self-service portals, and even talent management strategies.
• It’s important to note that both platforms may have additional contractor fees or extra cost items, particularly if your business has unique requirements such as multi-state payroll or needs around international contractors.

Special Features: Beyond the Basics

QuickBooks Time and Time Tracking Features

For business owners who value precise tracking of employee hours, QuickBooks Payroll’s integration with QuickBooks Time offers a robust time tracking feature. This integration allows for accurate tracking of employee hours, mileage tracking, and mobile time tracking which simplifies the recording of employee hours and attendance.

Benefits Administration and HR Capabilities in Gusto

Gusto isn’t solely a payroll solution—it’s a holistic benefits administration platform that supports a wide array of HR functions, including:

• Employee Self-Service Portal: Where employees can review their employee onboarding materials, submit employee surveys, and access a dedicated resource center for ongoing guidance.
• Benefits Management: Covers everything from health insurance coverage, vision insurance, to additional features like disability insurance, life insurance, and even college savings plans.
• Applicant Tracking and Job Posting: Gusto offers tools to support talent management and recruitment, seamlessly integrating applicant tracking with the rest of its payroll software capabilities.

Additional Payroll EnhancementsBoth QuickBooks and Gusto offer advanced reporting tools that enhance financial reporting and hire reporting. These advanced features support the creation of detailed financial reports, ensuring that small, medium-sized, and mid-sized businesses have exceptional financial visibility. These systems not only help in tracking payroll expenses but also streamline processes like tax preparation and automatic calculations for payroll taxes.

Expert Reviews and User Experience

When comparing Gusto vs QuickBooks for payroll, expert reviews often highlight that while QuickBooks Online Payroll excels in accounting integration and direct deposit speed, Gusto stands out in benefits administration and HR onboarding. Key points include:

• QuickBooks Payroll:
  
  
  
  • User-Friendly Interface: Known for its intuitive design, the platform ensures that even users with minimal accounting software experience can manage payroll management effectively.
  • Dedicated Support: Offers access to a dedicated support team and expert setup guidance which is ideal for business owners who require ongoing support and guidance on topics including tax payment and federal taxes.
  • Accounting Prowess: Fully integrates with QuickBooks Accounting, providing advanced features such as Advanced Reporting and Expert Assisted setup that enhance overall business operations.
• Gusto:
  
  
  
  • Comprehensive Payroll Package: Gusto’s full-service payroll covers both basic payroll and comprehensive solutions, including payroll before payday and auto payroll for both hourly and salaried employees.
  • Benefits Administration Capabilities: The platform’s focus on benefits management—including health benefits, health insurance, vision insurance, flexible spending accounts, and commuter benefits—ensures a robust benefits package for employees.
  • Employee Portal and Onboarding Tools: These features facilitate efficient employee onboarding, customizable employee profiles, and even background checks to ensure talent management is integrated from the start.

Making the Right Choice for Your Business

Ultimately, your decision between Gusto vs QuickBooks for payroll should reflect your business requirements, operational efficiency goals, and preference for integrated accounting systems. Here are some considerations to help guide your decision:

1. Accounting Integration:
   
   
   
   • QuickBooks Payroll is ideal if you’re already using QuickBooks Online or require a payroll solution that integrates naturally with your existing QuickBooks Accounting systems.
   • It streamlines the chart of accounts, supports bookkeeping automation, and ties in neatly with QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping for accurate financial reporting.
2. Employee Benefits and HR Integration:
   
   
   
   • Gusto shines when it comes to employee onboarding, benefits administration, and overall HR capabilities.
   • If your business values comprehensive employee benefits—such as health insurance benefits, flexible spending accounts, and commuter benefits—Gusto's resource center and employee self-service portal offer extensive support.
3. Cost Considerations and Pricing Structure:
   
   
   
   • Both platforms offer straightforward pricing structures; however, it is important to consider base fees, additional costs for extra employees or contractors, and the added value of additional features like mobile payroll apps, automatic calculations, and video tutorials.
   • Evaluate the fee per month and any extra cost components to determine which provider aligns with your financial planning and operational efficiency goals.
4. Advanced Features and Time Tracking:
   
   
   
   • For businesses that need enhanced time tracking features, QuickBooks Time integration with QuickBooks Online Payroll provides a reliable solution.
   • For those seeking robust contractor payments, multi-state payroll management, and comprehensive tracking of employee hours, both platforms offer essential tools—each with unique strengths.
5. Business Size and Scalability:
   
   
   
   • Consider whether your organization falls within the 0-49 Employees, (50-249 Employees, or (250-999 Employees categories.
   • QuickBooks Payroll often caters well to small and medium-sized businesses, while Gusto is highly adaptable for mid-sized businesses and firms requiring additional contractor management and international contractor payment support.

Choosing between Gusto vs QuickBooks for payroll ultimately comes down to aligning your payroll management strategy with your business operations and long-term goals. If seamless integration with accounting software, advanced financial reporting, and an intuitive user interface are your priorities, QuickBooks Online Payroll might be the best fit. Conversely, if you’re looking for a full-service payroll solution that places a strong emphasis on employee benefits, comprehensive HR tools, and flexible administration capabilities, Gusto stands out as a robust option.

Both systems provide automated tax calculations, options for same-day direct deposits or next-day deposit, and scalable pricing tiers that support a wide range of business sizes—from small businesses with basic payroll needs to mid-sized and larger companies requiring advanced reporting and integration capabilities. With features like direct deposit, unlimited payroll runs, expert product guidance, and dedicated support teams, either solution can help streamline your payroll processes and bolster your business’s financial health.

In making your decision, consider taking advantage of free trials or demos that many providers offer. Use these resources to delve into your selected provider's resource center, watch video tutorials, and explore their onboarding tools and employee self-service portal. With careful consideration of each platform’s integration capabilities, additional resources, and benefits administration capabilities, you can confidently choose the payroll solution that best meets your business requirements and supports your ongoing operational efficiency.

By leveraging the strengths of either QuickBooks Payroll or Gusto, you ensure that your payroll processes—from automatic tax calculations to comprehensive employee benefits—are efficiently managed, contributing to enhanced financial visibility, reduced payroll management complexities, and a positive experience for your employees. Ultimately, whether you opt for the accounting prowess of QuickBooks Online Payroll or the all-encompassing benefits administration of Gusto, your business will benefit from a streamlined, user-friendly interface designed to grow with your evolving needs.

‍