Gusto vs Wave: Which Payroll Solution Fits Your Business?

Struggling to manage the complexities of payroll processing while juggling HR responsibilities? You're not alone. Many business owners face challenges with inefficient software tools that lead to errors in tax filings, difficulty in handling payroll taxes, and inadequate employee self-service portals. Fortunately, switching to the right solution—whether it's Gusto or Wave—can streamline your process payroll and ensure employees happy while keeping additional costs to a minimum.

The Problem: Complex Payroll and HR Management

In today’s competitive market, companies with employees of various sizes need payroll software that delivers robust HR tools while simplifying essential tasks. Businesses often grapple with extensive requirements such as handling tax filings, managing a secure document vault, and offering benefits administration that includes health insurance plans from leading carriers like United Healthcare, vision benefits, and even retirement plans without unexpected extra cost. Without a comprehensive solution, you could face issues such as wage garnishment complications, manual expense tracking, and additional costs for features that should be part of the base price.

Whether you’re processing payroll runs for 1-10 employees or scaling up to 201-500 employees, the lack of features like employee self-service portals, Gusto's self-onboarding, and next-day direct deposit can impede smooth business operations. Moreover, managing individual profiles, team directories, and attendance tracking without a mobile app that supports direct deposit payments and real-time updates adds unnecessary complexity to payroll processes.

The Solution: Gusto vs Wave

Gusto: Comprehensive, Full-Service Payroll and HR

Gusto stands out as an all-in-one platform designed to process payroll efficiently and manage HR features seamlessly. With straightforward monthly plans starting at a $40-$80 base fee plus $6 per employee per month, Gusto delivers:

• Automatic Payroll Processing: With unlimited payrolls at no extra cost, Gusto enables immediate processing payroll across all 50 states, handling tax filings—including W-2, 1099, and year-end tax forms—automatically.
• Advanced HR Features: The platform offers employee self-service management and onboarding tools such as custom employee handbooks, onboarding checklists, and document e-signing processes. This enables active employee engagement through the employee self-service portal and lifetime employee access.
• Robust Benefits Administration: Gusto provides a comprehensive benefits package featuring traditional benefits, health insurance brokers offering affordable insurance options, vision benefits, and retirement plans—with licensed advisors ensuring that employees happy through a tailored benefits dashboard.
• Integrated Time Tracking and Onboarding: From time tracking for accurate employee hours to seamless onboarding checklists and dedicated onboarding support, Gusto’s key features empower companies to manage payroll software and HR functions efficiently.
• Integration Capabilities: With over 200 third-party integrations, including popular accounting platforms like QuickBooks Online and Dynamics 365 Business Central, Gusto’s suite of tools and software integrations simplifies expense management and bank reconciliation.

Additional standout features include commuter plans, direct deposit, and Gusto Wallet, which provides next-day direct deposit and facilitates electronic payment methods. These simplify payroll runs and eliminate any frustration stemming from extra costs or setup fees.

Wave Payroll: A Budget-Friendly, Accounting-Centric Option

Wave Payroll is the ideal choice for small businesses and freelancers who already rely on Wave Accounting Inc.’s suite of accounting software. Key highlights include:

• Cost-Effective Pricing: With a base fee as low as $20-$40 per month (depending on tax service state coverage) plus $6 per employee or per contractor monthly, Wave Payroll is a practical option for companies with tighter budgets.
• Integrated Accounting Tools: Wave Accounting offers robust expense tracking, receipt scanning, and bank account integration for seamless financial management, making it popular among solopreneurs and companies with minimal payroll complexities.
• Essential Payroll Features: It supports tax filings for W-2 forms in select states and provides necessary tax calculations. However, note that services like 1099 filing or complex payroll functionalities (e.g., wage garnishment) require additional manual input.
• Basic HR Support: Although Wave offers an employee self-service experience for managing W-2 and banking information, it lacks the extensive HR features found in Gusto, such as dedicated onboarding, time tracking, or custom employee handbooks.

Wave’s payroll platform is best suited for companies needing a free starter plan that integrates with their accounting software. However, the limited mobile app functionality and reduced customer support channels mean that while the base price is attractive, you may face challenges scaling as your business grows.

Making the Right Choice

When comparing Gusto vs Wave, consider your company’s current and future needs:

• For Full-Service Payroll and HR: If you require robust benefits administration, unlimited payrolls, employee self-service features, direct deposit, time tracking, and comprehensive integrations with other software tools, Gusto is your ideal choice. Its dedicated customer support team, which includes live support via phone, email, and chat, as well as its unbiased user reviews boasting a high average user rating, attest to its standout features.
• For Basic, Budget-Friendly Accounting Solutions: If your primary need is expense management and simplified accounting processes without the extensive HR features, Wave provides a straightforward payroll service without additional complexities, making it a practical solution for companies with limited budgets.

In conclusion, both platforms offer unique advantages. Gusto and Wave each deliver essential payroll functionalities and process payroll services tailored to different business operations. Assess the detailed pricing plan info, integration capabilities, and HR tools like employee time tracking or benefits administration, and then choose the one that aligns with your organizational needs and workforce management strategy.By weighing these comprehensive features—from tax filings to mobile payroll options—you can confidently decide which solution ensures that your employees are happy and your payroll processes are as efficient as possible.

‍